Buffett’s wager on S&P 500 vs. hedge funds: Year 7

Print Friendly

OSBON_017How time flies. It’s now been seven years since Warren Buffett wagered one million dollars that an S&P 500 index fund would outperform the picks of a prominent hedge fund manager over a ten-year period. Another year of returns is in. Who’s ahead?

Protege Partners must now hate this time of year
You may recall this bet. We report on its progress every year. Mr. Buffett’s premise in 2008 was simply that the universally available S&P 500 index would beat hedge funds over the next decade. Protégé Partners, a hedge fund firm in New York took the challenge, pitting a mix of five handpicked funds against the index. The winner’s charity of choice will receive at least one million dollars in 2018.

Big lead widensdesire2-1
The first year of the bet – you may recall the Great Recession – was a big mess for both sides, with the index falling farther than the hedge funds. But since then, the S&P has prevailed handily. The cumulative result at this point is the S&P index up 63 percent while the still unidentified hedge funds have managed only a 19 percent gain over seven years.

The one-year result is similar. In 2014, Buffett’s side gained 13 percent and Protégé’s less than six.

Clear lessons
We write about this wager every year as it reminds us of three very important investing principles.

First, long-term returns are so much more important to the individual investor than daily, quarterly or annual performance. Watching these two different investing approaches over a decade is a great lesson for all of us. Although the financial media is obsessed with playing short-term events for quick profits, prudent investing is a long-term exercise in patience and discipline.

Second, having more tools does not guarantee better results. Remember that hedge funds can make frequent adjustments in holdings, can sell short, can use derivatives, and can jump in or out of cash to time the latest economic and political news. The S&P 500 index has none of these options, yet is way ahead of the more agile Protégé picks. As we often see in investing, making fewer decisions, predictions and trades is often the best strategy.

Last and just as important, the far lower fee structure of the index investment is a big advantage versus the hedge funds which may be siphoning off two percent and more in performance each year to pay its managers. (Pretty good deal, getting paid handsomely to get trounced by the S&P year after year.)

Three more to go

Tune in next year for another update. A good competition with real money on the line brings out the best for investors to choose from.

John Osbon – josbon@osboncapital.com


This article intended to provide general information only and should not be construed as an offer of specifically tailored individualized advice. Various factors could cause actual results or performance to differ materially from those discussed in forward-looking statements contained herein.

An investment cannot be made directly in an index.

Specific securities identified and described may or may not be held in portfolios managed by the Adviser and do not represent all of the securities purchased, sold, or recommended for advisory clients. The reader should not assume that investments in the securities identified and discussed were or will be profitable.

Any references to third-party data or opinions are listed for informational purposes only and have not been verified for accuracy by the Adviser. Adviser does not endorse the statements, services or performance of any third-party vendor without specifically assessing the suitability of a third-party to a client’s or a prospective client’s needs and objectives.

Unless otherwise indicated, reference to any vendors, investment managers or funds are purely illustrative and should not be construed as endorsements of their services or offerings.